Women’s quotas? Why perception and attitude determine success

Women’s quotas can boost work engagement among both women and men, provided they are perceived as a sign of a fair corporate culture. A new study by the University of Mannheim reveals why it is not just the introduction of quotas that matters, but above all a company’s underlying values and how they are communicated. The key insight for practice: The signaling power of women’s quotas is underestimated.

In boardrooms, the debate on women’s quotas is usually framed as a structural issue, aimed at meeting statutory or internal requirements: how many seats on supervisory boards or executive boards need to be filled to comply with the guidelines? Time and again, the discussion focuses on requirements and on what ‘must’ be implemented. 

However, new research by Torsten Biemann, Professor of Management at the University of Mannheim, shows that women’s quotas have a far-reaching psychological impact on the entire workforce. They act as powerful signals from an organization, indicating which values, attitudes and performance criteria actually matter there. 

Together with his co-author Madleen Meier-Barthold from the Rotterdam School of Management, Professor Biemann investigates the extent to which employees are aware of the quota regulations within the company and how this influences their work. The research is based on data from the “Linked Personnel Panel,” a representative German dataset that links more than 2,200 employer and employee reports. The sample includes private-sector companies with more than 50 employees during the 2016–2017 period and comprises organizations both with and without legal obligations, allowing the researchers to examine whether these obligations influence employees’ attitudes toward quotas. 

The findings show that, provided employees are aware of and recognize the existence of a women’s quota within the company, it increases work engagement among both women and men equally. This effect stems from the promotion of a fair corporate culture, rather than from personal prospects for promotion. 

How employees interpret a women’s quota 

According to the principles of signaling theory, company management conveys implicit messages about corporate culture through HR measures, such as the introduction of a women’s quota. As employees cannot directly observe the actual, underlying motives and values of top managers, they use visible decisions to draw conclusions about the corporate culture. 

The researchers’ data show that when an employee perceives a women’s quota in the workplace, their work engagement increases significantly (as measured by the scientifically established UWES-9 scale). This effect stems from the fact that employees interpret and perceive the quota as an indicator of a fair, progressive and ethical working environment. 

Of particular significance here is the empirical refutation of the assumption that women are more motivated by quotas than men. The researchers demonstrate that, in terms of their engagement dynamics, men react just as positively to the perceived quota signal as women. The widespread fear that men would react to quotas across the board with reactance, devaluation or status anxieties can thus be dispelled. The signal of a fair and progressive working environment carries more weight than individual career calculations. 

The perception gap between corporate reality and employees’ views 

However, in practice, a signal can only have an effect if it actually reaches the recipients at the very first stage – that of perception. It is precisely here that the study reveals a glaring weakness in corporate reality. Guidelines formally adopted by the management board by no means guarantee that they are actually recognized by the workforce. In the absence of this awareness, even the most carefully crafted quota scheme remains ineffective in terms of employee engagement. 

A comparison of the actual reality within the company with employees’ perceptions reveals significant gaps in information and misconceptions. Formal quota decisions often fail to filter through to the workplace. Across all groups, only 68 per cent of employees correctly assess the reality of their company’s quotas – the error rate is therefore 32 per cent. Women have a significantly higher accuracy rate than men, which can be explained by the fact that, as the primary target group of gender equality measures, women have a greater personal stake in the issue and therefore actively scan their working environment for relevant information. To counteract this information gap, many companies rely on proactive communication of targets. The data show that proactive communication drastically reduces the failure to recognize a quota – particularly among men. 

The ‘paragraph effect’: Why quota requirements stifle staff engagement 

Following the introduction in 2015/2016 of the Act on Equal Participation of Women and Men in Leadership Positions (FüPoG I), listed companies and those with equal co-determination in Germany were required to set binding targets for the proportion of women on their executive boards, at the highest levels of management and on their supervisory boards. This provides an ideal empirical comparison between voluntarily set quotas and statutory requirements. 

The comparison reveals a marked shift in employee response. 

If a company introduces a quota without being legally obliged to do so, and this is recognized by employees, work engagement increases significantly.   The workforce interprets the measure as an intrinsic, value-based decision by senior management. 

If the company is subject to a statutory obligation to meet a women’s quota, the positive effect on employee engagement disappears almost entirely.  If the company is subject to a legal obligation, employees attribute management’s actions to external factors – such as avoiding sanctions, mere compliance with bureaucratic requirements, or PR calculations. The signal loses its effectiveness as an honest indicator of the organization's intrinsic values. 

What does this mean for management and policymakers? 

The World Economic Forum’s (WEF) Global Gender Gap Report 2026 shows that there remains a significant need for gender equality measures to bring about structural change at the top of large companies and to spur sluggish organization's into action. Furthermore, the research findings by Biemann and Meier-Barthold show that companies can generate considerable benefits if they communicate and implement such measures correctly. 

However, corporate leadership must understand that a gender equality policy aimed purely at meeting targets falls short. To trigger the proven engagement effect that a quota for women can have across the wider workforce, companies would do well to communicate it as a commitment to a fair corporate culture for all. Even if companies are legally obliged to meet the quota, they should communicate that the measure is based on the company’s values and long-term vision, and that it is implemented out of genuine conviction and seen as an opportunity – not as a burdensome compliance obligation. 

HR departments should also use regular staff surveys to check whether diversity measures are even being recognized, and take targeted action to close any information gaps. 

In their research, Madleen Meier-Barthold and Torsten Biemann demonstrate that genuine equality boosts performance when it is not enforced by the written law but is embedded in the minds and attitudes of the organization. 

Key findings 

Women’s quotas generate far-reaching, positive performance boosts for the entire organization. 

Men respond just as positively to a women’s quota in terms of their commitment to work as women do. Quotas act as signals that convey an organization's values to its employees. 

However, organizations must ensure that formal measures to promote equality are actually taken on board by staff. 

If employees view the quota scheme merely as a means of fulfilling an obligation – for example, to avoid sanctions – the positive impact on staff performance is lost. 

Link to the chair: Biemann | Fakultät für Betriebswirtschaftslehre | Universität Mannheim 

Link to the paper: Signaling Effects of Women's Quotas: An Analysis of Workforce Perceptions and Reactions 

Back